The food was fantastic as usual and the service staff very attentive. The inside felt a mixture of industrial and Bayview-esque. My only gripes are the price of a single slice of pie was very expensive, even for being homemade, and the Bloody Mary didn't have any flavor to it. Definitely worth the stop.

My updated review to Honeypie continues to be 5 stars. They are the best breakfast in Bay View. I love everything I get there. When we go, we are usually there just before 9, lined up to get in. In fact my only complaint is that they are t open early in the morning. The breakfast casserole is probably my favorite item on the menu u but I do also rotate in the breakfast sandwich from time to time. The back patio is beautiful and makes you forget you are in a city.

Great bloody Mary's! Great food. Nice portions. Not ridiculous. When we left, we discussed that we would actually make the drive from Chicago to have breakfast there and then spend the day in Milwaukee. We sat at the bar, which I thought was best. Nice vibe at the bar. There was an outside patio but it looked underwhelming. Even the main dining room was a bit lacking. Waitstaff was friendly. Not rushed; but attentive. I had a beef hash. Was going to go with biscuits and gravy; glad I didn't because I can have that anywhere. The beef hash was exceptional and unique. Didn't try the pie. Maybe next time. We arrived just before they opened and there was a line waiting to get in. So it gets busy. It's not a secret!

Wow! Wow! Wow! Cozy and cute decor with beautiful wall paper. Our server was friendly, knowledgeable and attentive to all of our needs (even with a little one). Now to the food....The Hopplepopple was incredible! Great serving size (for me.....). It was so flavorful and protein filled. I added a side of sausage gravy as the restaurant is known for their gravy. Every bite seemed to get better and better as I worked my way through it. Absolutely phenomenal! My sister had the Denver omelette and the ham inside was amazing. My brother-in-law had the breakfast casserole - So filling but absolutely delicious. We had the Salted Honey Pie and the Chocolate Hazelnut pie. They looked so good that I forgot to take a picture. They were both gone in a matter of minutes. Sorry I didn't get any photos but they were both incredible. Very happy we made the trip from WhiteFish Bay. Incredible experience. Nice work!

Absolutely incredible food, and the pie is even better! The breakfast burrito was so good, would definitely order again. This is a very busy place for breakfast/brunch, but if you go early there's usually no wait!

This was a long time bookmark and the new restaurant of week which is very popular for weekend brunch and has a line waiting before they even open. I got there 25 minutes early to get a table and the which I did because it completely filled up in minutes. The server tried to offer me counter seat vs a booth because it was only me. F that because I'm not spending $40 with tip for breakfast just to eat at a lunch counter like George Webb. The decor is like library casual and nicely done. I ordered the Bloody Mary spicy with the breakfast casserole right away so my food came quick before anyone else because I knew exactly what I wanted. The Bloody Mary was average and not too spicy with an olive, green bean and chunk of meat stick. The breakfast casserole looked amazing with the sunny side up egg and baked melted cheese. The breakfast casserole is biscuits, roasted potatoes, sausage gravy, white cheddar, bacon topped with a sunny side up egg. This was so amazing and delicious, just a genius idea. The bacon was completely drowned out by the super chunky sausage gravy. The sausage stood out as flavorful so the biscuits and gravy must be very good on its own because it was great in the casserole. The economy must not be that bad because lately I'm running into packed restaurants with wait lines if you don't get there at first open, I was in and out in 30 minutes with a packed restaurant and people waiting. This is a great brunch spot and the breakfast casserole is very unique and a must try, great job honeypie.

I've been to honey pie about 3 times now. Every time it is fantastic! When you walk in your greeted by the host stand. Typically they seat you before the original time they gave. There's places to sit inside and the doorway never gets to crowded. The decor inside is eclectic farmhouse grandma. Try also have the pie case at the front so you can prepare for you choice later. Once seated they provide water for the table right away. This time I got the porkslaw sandwich. The aioli they use to sooooo good. Just be prepared for it to be messy. I've gotten this sandwich the past two times because every time it is fantastic.

Wow! This place was amazing. We came here for lunch and it didn't disappoint. I had the mushroom melt and it was so good. The bread was delicious and the flavor was great! I also ordered the MKE mud pie and that was so chocolatey and rich. I highly recommend coming here and can't wait to come back to try something new!

Honeypie is busy on weekend mornings. I went for brunch and there was a wait for a table at 10:30 or so in the morning. The fans of this place are devoted. But they don't take reservations and the line moves fast. There's patio seating available also. They have delicious brunch. I've had the ham biscuit and the breakfast burrito at brunch. I would recommend getting something that comes with a biscuit. Judging from my neighbors' plates the breakfast casserole and the pork fries are also popular. Even if you go not sure if you want pie, between the temptation of the pie case and all the slices you see going out around you, you're probably going to get pie. And you should. It's pricey, but their pies are really good. The slices are large enough to split between two people. You can taste that they use quality ingredients and they feature some creative flavor combinations as well as some classics like key lime and cherry. Service was a little swamped at times, but friendly and helpful. But when I stepped away to look at the pie case, a different server from mine cleared my table including my water and juice glass and silverware. I chalk it to it being a busy morning. My server brought me another water and fork with my delicious blueberry lemon pie.